Return of Rail

Discussion of the June 25 event has begun on Masslive.com and is producing some interesting reading. For one example, read this article on the return of rail.

April 10, 2008

John R. Stilgoe: ‘Train travel will supplant highway and air travel in the next few decades. Furthermore, electric railroads will increasingly be used to distribute freight items as well as mail and express packages.’
Staff photo Will Nunnally/Harvard News Office

It seems responses fall into 3 major types: whole-hearted supporters (a majority), supportive skeptics, and critics. Among the supportive skpetics, there are lots of questions about details. One poster engaged in a discussion, even seeking out information (like that article above). That is what the discussion needs--more information, not less. Among the critics, there are reminders that we have buses. Buses and cars and planes don't solve all transportation problems. Neither does rail--BUT if we avoid using one mode because we are worried about the impact on another, that does us a disservice. Historically, positive developments have resulted in regions with commuter rail. Our region does not have a good public transportation system. It's getting better, but too slowly.

June 25 Event

You are welcome to attend the release of the

Report to Highlight Need for Better Transportation Options ...Officials and transit advocates point to New Haven--Hartford--Springfield commuter rail

WHAT: MASSPIRG is coordinating a press conference to make the case for better public transportation options and release a new report that analyzes the average household's federal economic stimulus rebate compared to the average household's spending on gasoline.

MASSPIRG will be releasing the report with local and state officials, commuter rail advocates, and the regional planning commission to highlight the revitalization of Union Station and proposed commuter rail connecting New Haven to Hartford to Springfield, and eventually all the way to Vermont.

WHO: Phineas Baxandall, MASSPIRG Senior Policy Analyst
Timothy Brennan, Pioneer Valley Planning Commission Executive Director
David Panagore, Chief Development Officer for the City of Springfield
Rebecca Townsend with Pioneer Valley Advocates for Commuter Rail
Cheryl Coakley-Rivera, Springfield State Representative
Kevin Kennedy from Congressman Neal's office

WHY: This month, the average price of gasoline in Massachusetts hit $4.00 a gallon. In response, transit ridership has surged, but too many commuters are without transit options.

With many transit expansion projects planned, high gas prices make it clear that these types of investments must move forward. Plus, the current federal transportation funding system expires in 2009, presenting an opportunity to see more federal funding dedicated to public transportation.

WHEN: Wednesday, June 25th, 2008, 11:30 AM.

WHERE: Springfield Union Station

Subsidies

Reuters has a Q& A with Amtrak President Alex Kummantwith at that link. Among the fascinating things, we find out how much other modes of transportation are subsidized:

Q: Is there a goal for Amtrak to be profitable, and should it be profitable?
A: "I think it is absolute mythology that there's any national system that is profitable. And I think the naysayers just have to get over it. There is no example. If you peel apart the British rail privatization, there were a tremendous numbers of problems with that. People say Oh look at these wonderful new trains running around here. It's all because of the miracle of the private market.' That's complete nonsense. There's a bunch of new trains running around there because they spent five times as much tax money today as they did in 1990. And actually if you look at the subsidy structures, we are awash in subsidies for all modes of transportation. There's a $10 billion a year cash transfer from the general fund to the Highway Trust Fund. FAA gets $2.7 billion. We pay all security at Amtrak and yet there is a $1.5 billion subsidy that goes beyond any user fees for security in air travel.
There's $8 billion that goes into security and life safety for cruise ships. There's four-plus billion dollars that goes to waterways. Let's not even get into airport construction which is a miasma of state, federal and local tax breaks and tax refinancing and God knows what. And then there's private aviation which gets huge subsidies in accelerated depreciation loss for small aircraft. So I always get a good chuckle, if I'm in a good mood, when people talk about subsidized Amtrak. It's always a lot of fun then to reel off every other mode that is subsidized. And one final point. If you actually look at the amount of public capital that flows into the rail network per passenger, it's like $40 a passenger for Amtrak and $500 to $700 per automobile out there through the highways.
One final point is that the network matters. So you can find some juicy little piece of railroad that has just the right density and say Wow we make money here'. But guess what? If you peel that out and privatize it, your costs for running the rest of the network just went up. And it's actually connectivity that matters. So it's an entire network that matters. And if you don't have an entire network, you end up with a ridiculous patchwork of short little lanes of things that make no sense from a national system."

Next meeting 6/19

Reminder

Our June 19 meeting will be at 7:30, in the Lathrop House Bed & Breakfast at 188 Sumner Ave., Springfield, MA.

Among other items, we will discuss:

-The Future of Transportation Meeting
-A National Corridors Initiative connection
-PVACR's recent meeting with the CT DOT Environmental Assessment team

And, of course, we will discuss how the new Transportation Bond Bill & Amtrak re-authorization affects our work.

Please also keep this on your calendar:

PVACR-MassPIRG event 6/25 11:30am @ Union Station (if you can't come, be sure you watch the news)

Bond Bill 2: The sequel's better than the first

Thanks to Dan Ring for bringing this to our attention:

The House will vote on Bond Bill 2 tomorrow, Wednesday, June 11.

6001-0804 For the purpose of implementing rail improvements under chapter 161C of the General Laws; provided, that funds may be used for transportation planning, design, permitting and engineering for heavy rail, light rail and bus projects, which shall include the Urban Ring, Blue Line extension to Lynn, the Connecticut River Knowledge Corridor Line and South Coast initiatives; provided, however, that that the extension of the Blue Line to Lynn shall be restricted to existing commuter rail rights of way excluding narrow gauge rail line rights of way; provided further, that funds may be used for the acquisition of interests in land; provided further, that $220,000 shall be expended for Phase II disabled accessibility renovations at the rail depot in the town of Athol; and provided further, that $50,000 shall be expended to study the feasibility of constructing a Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority Commuter Rail station in the town of West Bridgewater.........................$90,000,000

(more to come)

Just Take Public Transportation

"...Or taking public transportation."

The Globe's reporting of a survey about gas prices changing travel habits includes that deceptively small line. Public transportation, if available, would enable communities to remain stable, reducing the transient population of talent and creativity, of community-minded folks who also want to work in interesting jobs. Or, let's face it, if the only job you can get is in a place you cannot afford to live in, you are stuck. Look at Western New England.....transportation choices.

Increasing # of Train Commuters

It would be nice to flock to a train to save money and conserve energy.....people in Boston have that option. The Boston Globe has this graphic to accompany their article today about commuters increasing their use of the T:

It seems that Secretary Cohen understands the significance of trains to the region: ""We want to keep these riders," said state Transportation Secretary Bernard Cohen. "It's not good for the region if people try the T and then go back to their cars.""